How to automatically hold high-risk orders on Shopify
Short answer: To stop high-risk Shopify orders shipping before you look, hold them automatically: use Shopify Flow to hold high-risk orders for review,[1] or an app such as Estre that places a fulfilment hold with its reasons and waits for you to press Approve or Block.[3] Prefer holding to auto-cancelling, because real customers are sometimes flagged high risk.
Updated 19 November 2026 · Estre is made by Misimi Corp.
Should I hold, capture or cancel a risky order?
| Option | What happens | Effort | Risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Review by hand | You check every flagged order before fulfilling[2] | High at volume | Orders ship if someone misses one |
| Shopify Flow: hold | A workflow holds high-risk orders for manual review[1] | Medium: build the workflow | Low |
| Shopify Flow: cancel and restock | A workflow cancels orders that meet your criteria[1] | Medium | Good orders flagged by mistake are lost |
| Estre | Holds risky orders with reasons; Approve ships, Block cancels and refunds[3] | Low: install, start in Watch mode | Low |
How do I set up automatic holds with Estre?
- Install and start in Watch mode. Estre reports what it would flag and hold, and changes nothing.
- Read a week of flags. Each one lists its reasons, in the app and in the order's fraud analysis in Shopify.
- Turn on protection. High-risk orders get a fulfilment hold so they cannot ship before you look. Secure Pro also holds medium-risk orders.[3]
- Decide each hold. Approve releases the hold and the order ships. Block cancels and refunds it.
- Contact the customer when unsure. Shopify suggests verifying a high-risk order before cancelling it.[2]
Why not cancel automatically?
A high-risk recommendation is a prediction. Shopify's options for a high-risk order are to verify it, cancel it or refund it,[2] and automatic cancelling removes the verify step. Holding keeps both outcomes open at the cost of a click. Fulfilling high-risk orders without review, on the other hand, can lead to chargebacks and, in the worst case, removal from Shopify Payments.[2]
Related: bot protection without Plus · what to do when Shopify marks an order high risk.
What does a lost chargeback cost? Our estimate
Estimate, not a measurement: Estre's own arithmetic. On Shopify Payments in the United States each chargeback carries a $15 fee, returned only if you win.[4] A lost one also costs the order you shipped. The order value below is an example, not an average.
| Chargebacks lost a month | Estimated cost a month |
|---|---|
| 1 | US$75 |
| 3 | US$225 |
| 10 | US$750 |
The goods themselves, shipping and your time on each dispute come on top. Holding a risky order before it ships is how you avoid the chargeback in the first place.
How much does Estre cost?
| Plan | What it includes |
|---|---|
| Free | Flags bot sign-ups and risky orders; judges 100 orders a month; every flag explained |
| Secure | Every order judged; holds risky orders until you Approve or Block; bulk clean-up of bot accounts; 7-day free trial |
| Secure Pro | Everything in Secure; checkout guard blocks bots and bulk buys; holds medium-risk orders too; 7-day free trial |
Prices are shown on the App Store listing in your store's billing currency.
What do people ask about Estre?
Can Shopify automatically hold high-risk orders?
Yes, with Shopify Flow you can build a workflow that holds high-risk orders for review. Apps such as Estre do it without building a workflow.
Should I auto-cancel high-risk orders?
Usually not. Real customers are sometimes flagged high risk. Holding lets you verify first; cancelling loses the sale.
Does a hold stop the payment?
A fulfilment hold stops the order shipping. Whether payment is captured depends on your payment capture settings.
What does Block do in Estre?
It cancels and refunds the order.
Does Estre hold medium-risk orders?
On Secure Pro, yes. Secure holds high-risk orders.
Try Estre in Watch mode first. It shows what it would flag or hold before it changes anything. Free plan available.